may contain spoilers:



I just finished reading it and it is by far the best batman graphic novel i have ever read. I literally could not put it down. Everything about it was well executed. I liked the inclusion of all the major batman villains (although the penguins cameo was hollow).

The big question remains . . . who is Holiday?

Of course their has to be more then one Holiday . . . Antonio, Gilda and Dent seem to be the main culprits. The problem is i believe Antonio faked his death to hide from the real Holiday and is only taking the credit for the fame.

Gilda thought Harvey was responsible for killing Antonio but it's obvious Antonio was not murdered so there are holes in her assumption. I'm almost convinced that Gilda was responsible for all but Maroni. The Riddler did state that the handgun was perfect for a woman. Although Gilda does make the claim that someone after the new years killing took her place. Plus Holiday had to be a sharp shooter and it is never stated the marksmanship of any of the suspects.

Why did Holiday spare the Riddler? To have one of the craziest villains in Gotham know the answer to the greatest mystery? He had to have seen who it was. At least give a decent description but yet in his terror he never reveals to batman who Holiday is. It could be the riddler is being selfish and wishes to keep the secret to his grave.

Who do you think Holiday is?