I could barely watch that episode to begin with. "Hush" was the best episode because:
1) There was little to no cheese diolage
2) Tara was introduced, my favorite minor character of the series
3) There was no SING!
When i was young, i was one of those kids that fast forward through most of the singing in a Disney movie. I'll watch a musical scene once but 9/10 i'll skip it the second time around. But even i will admit, "You never had a friend like me" from Aladdin is the best Disney song ever.
But yah, i can't believe they made a play based on that episode. I liked the series but that was one episode that people like a little too much. Also, has anyone read any of these:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffy_the_Vampire_Slayer_Season_Eight