Okay, I feel compelled to break this down one by one. Maybe I can help translate them from the seriously annoying 'Broken-Hearted Girleese":
1. Commitment. Lets get it figured out men! No players! –JW
Well okay, this one seems fair enough. Neither sex likes their partner screwing around on them. (Although forgiveness if it happens, depending on the circumstances, is probably important too.)
2. Communication. (Tell me what you are feeling ahead of time so we are on the same freakin’ page! Seriously!) – LK
This is a little vague, but I understand what she means I think. Don't bottle stuff up and then hit your partner with a bunch of emotional shit out of nowhere. Bad for a relationship. Annoying way of phrasing it, but I'm also gonna call this one fair as long as it goes both ways.
3. Attractive. (Why isn’t this #1? Ha ha)- LK
In her defense, she's just been dumped. In reality...WHAT century are we living in again?
5. Compassion (Don’t be cold and callused (as he called himself last night), have a heart and use it dang it) –LK
If ANYONE you know doesn't have this, you probably shouldn't be hanging around them at all, let alone *dating* him. Again, I know she feels like shit right now, but..

I think the guy was obviously just looking for an excuse to get out of there.
6. Honesty. Don’t LIE about everything! –JW
Or at least don't let the other person find out about it.

THis is kind of a no-brainer again. No one wants to be lied to.
7. Attractive. (Why isn’t this #1? Ha ha)- LK
Didn't we already have this one?
8. Ability to make me smile at any moment- SC
I didn't realize that was in the significant other job description... (Although honestly, I don't think they mean it's the *guys* responsibility to always try and make his girl smile; its that it's a big part of a relationship, period. I mean all your best friends make you laugh, right? Hell, its half the reason I hang out on this forum. If two people don't share a sense of humor, its probably a bad match.
9. Rock-hard ABS—JW
....
.......No comment. *sigh*
10. Believes in ghosts. –LK
Okay, this one is TOTALLY out of left field. What the fuck? All I can think is that maybe her guy broke up with her over a fight regarding this point, otherwise there would be NO reason for this to be on here. Most of the others contributing to this list seem sane, but this...wtf?
11. Kills spiders….especially if they’re in the shower- SC
Excuse me while I go puke, please.
And godammit, everyone fucking knows you don't kill spiders in the shower anyway, unless they're the deadly variety. You take them outside and let them go, murderer.
12. Wants to DO things with you. Like most of the time –JW
I thought this was kind of the definition of a relationship, myself. If a guy (or girl) is finding excuses not to do things with you, guess what? You aren't a couple anymore!
13. Will buy you flowers just because it’s Wednesday (meaning… just because…with no real reason at all) –LK
Oh for pete's sake. Yeah its nice when a guy does little things out of nowhere to surprise you like that, but its hardly *necessary.*
14. Will stand by you through tough times-AC
Um...duh?
15. Calls me just to tell me a random story that I probably won’t fully understand
since I wasn’t there…and…let’s me do the same to him- SC
Okay this one I don't understand at all. Seriously. I have two really good friends (one guy and one girl actually) who do this to me all the fucking time, and it drives me *insane.* This is not ideal, this describes someone who would drive me crazy if I lived in the same house with them.
16. Knows how to play an instrument. - LK
I don't get why this is on the list either. This is getting oddly specific now. "Oh yes, you're perfect, you love me, you care about me in every way...but until you learn how to play piano, asshole, hit the road."
17. Knows what to DO with HIS instrument – JW
*sigh* I was waiting for this one.
18. Wants to meet my family and wants me to meet his. –LK
If he doesn't, there's probably a big problem, and you should RUN AWAY. This is another one that falls into the "duh" category. Another clue into how this breakup happened, I think.
19. Does not want to hang out at the bars all the time. - JW
*scratches head*. ...Fair enough I guess. I don't suppose a guy would want his girl constantly hanging out somewhere else, either. I dunno, this one is weird.
20. Wants to be active—go out and do things we both (or at least do some things that he knows I like) would like to do. Like, go for walks, stargaze, play tennis, play golf. Not just sit in front of the TV and watch movies every time we hang out. –LK
More clues! Again, this has to be a two-way street though. If you want him to take you stargazing one night, its only fair you agree to go to the WWE event/monster truck rally/art gallery/the sort of place he'd like to go when he asks. That part's not implied here, so it fails and comes off sounding self-centered and egotistical.
21. Will offer to fix things around the house. And knows what he is doing –JW
Helping out around the house is fair, if you both live there. But for fuck's sake woman, do I have to come to your house and teach you how to use a frigging hammer and wrench?
22. Becomes friends with all of my friends, and their boyfriends/significant others. So we all can hang out a lot together –LK
Okay, this is a BAD idea imho. Of course you should be cool/on speaking terms with each others friends. And hanging out together at a party or something sometimes is cool. But overall, I think he hangs out with his friends/she hangs out with hers. Forcing your significant other on your pre-relationship friends almost never ends well. Bad bad BAD!
23. Lets me stay for all nine innings of the baseball game. --SC
Okay, this one I totally agree with just because any time my dad would take me to a baseball game, he would make us leave at the 7th inning stretch to "beat traffic." I HATED that. If we're gonna see a baseball game, LET ME WATCH THE FUCKING BASEBALL GAME! (Sorry. Personal pet peeve of mine.)
That said, I don't know many guys who do this. My dad's an asshole, and an exception to a lot of things.
24. Says I look better without makeup - JW
But I thought he wasn't supposed to lie.
No woman is stupid enough to think makeup doesn't improve her appearance. That's why we wear the goddamn stuff even though it fucking sucks. I know where they're going with this, the whole 'like me for who I am, not what I look like while all prettied up' thing, and I guess that's true, but
25. CANNOT be:
· A musician
· A doctor
· A lawyer
Needs to have a NORMAL job with the same hours as you do…….--JW
Okay, this is the first one that makes me come right out and say, "FUCK YOU BITCH."
First of all, I thought you wanted him to play a fucking instrument. Also, I guess he can't be a policeman, firefighter, soldier, or any other service profession. Because God forbid his job requires taking care of someone besides YOU. Fuck THAT shit.
26. Is proud of something that I am proud of—is happy and excited for me when I am excited about something. Like a new townhouse. Instead of shaking his head or mentioning that he didn’t like the idea—LK
Uh huh. I'm beginning to really form a picture of exactly how this breakup went down.
27. IS NOT FULL OF EXCUSES – JW
Well, yeah. Again, an obvious, two-way street thing. These are getting old. I'm surprised "must be able to breathe" is not on here yet.
28. Says everything always looks good on you –JW
BUT HE'S NOT SUPPOSED TO LIE!!!!
Maybe I'm the only one, but I'd rather be told I look like shit (okay, maybe not in those exact terms, but you get the idea) than actually go out looking like shit.
29. …and means it because he is completely attracted to you. –LK
AHHHH! Because you can't be attracted to someone unless you ALWAYS think they look like a pretty pretty princess 100% of the time. Dear God, I hate this woman.
30. Will not consider a break-up to be the 1st choice when a relationship is dealing with problems. --LK
I think I can safely say, darling, after reading the rest of your contributions to this list, that that says more about you at this point than it does about him.
Anyway, that's my take. Feel free of course to throw in your two cents about my two cents.