If you want to have some fun playing magic, I'll be more than happy to play some people. Of any playing level, throw me a PM of what time, and whether it's over IRC or OCTGN, and i'll see if can make that time : ).

-Snow

Quote:

Revised quite heavily after advise from pretty much everyone, mostly Fernin and Jeebus.

*Cries* at least you took my advice of listening to others : ).

I must say, Deck looks much better, don't recognize many of the cards, but the Nacatyl is a great card, even in your dual land deck, I'm guessing with your current card choices it's was one of the best to put in. The Llanowar elves also.. it's like playing 2 lands in one turn with them around. Boa's are also very sexy.

You have to work with your card pool, but here are some cards that really jumped out at me to replace if possible: Goblin Mountaineer (if you had more equip cards or enchantments might keep him), Acidic Slime (way to much mana for what it does), Heartwood (this is good vs indestructible but honestly if you kill the creature, you can do damage later, up to you though), and maybe drop one or two of your other high mana cost cards. and replace them with 4 or less mana costing cards. You may want to up the total # of creatures as well.

It's a good start have fun and play with it.
You'll rarely see in a deck just one of card, you'll likely see at least 2 if not 4. So if there is a card you're finding useful look at E-bay, Craigslist, or here even for getting more copies.

Quote:

My head may explode from how horribly that post was worded

Didn't know my posts gave orgasms!

Quote:

Wild Nacatl is a great creature, but NOT for your deck. Since you have no plains, he can only ever be a 2/2.

Please understand that he has a LIMITED CARD pool, and i point that out... so likely a 2/2 for one which it will probably be.. is good out of his choices. I think you're wrong here jeebus.



On the acidic slime i was thinking about telling you to SB it, sorry if i under estimated it though, i didn't read the or land. option it's more versatile than I thought, I could agree with a SB, since it is useful in case you need extra removal in one of those areas, but until you play an opponent hard to tell if you're going to actually need it.

Though with mana acceleration and that acidic slime card destroying an opponents land early can be devastating. With your current deck I personally wouldn't MB, but if Jeebus is telling you to keep it, I guess keep it. I personally would take it out though, even after noticing it can destroy a land.

I shouldn't have to avoid giving my opinion, right or wrong. And on top of that I am encouraging deferring to Jeebus, even though i think we're giving the same advice most of the time (I'm even saying it first).

Quote:

You shouldn't give it if it's been made clear numerous times that nobody wants to hear it.

I personally think they're just being bitter and actively trying to create holes what i'm saying.

I'll say:

Quote:

maybe drop one or two of your other high mana cost cards. and replace them with 4 or less mana costing cards

Jeebus Said:

Quote:

It's a good card for a really, really fast deck, but you have too many high mana spells to ever empty your hand, and even if you do you have better things to do with that mana, like Ant Queen or Flameblast Dragon.

This to me READS as take out some of your high costing cards you have too many they're going to just sit in your hand, because you'll be playing that mana on other more worthwhile things such as ant queen.

I don't agree with that logic totally, that's a small part of why you should do it the main reason, in my opinion, to cut out some high costing cards is the following:


I would argue differently as to why not to have so many high costing cards. With his current mana acceleration he's very likely to draw one or two of them early game before he can play them, meaning he's having dead draws.

We have the same conclusion you're giving a different reason, and i thought of your EXACT reason before posted, but i did not state that because I made the more relevant reason he NEEDED to cut some down. Namely early game dead draws.

There are numerous other cases where we've said the same stuff exactly, maybe i didn't explain the suggestion thoroughly, but i could if i wanted to make my post 2 pages long, on exactly all the reasons to make the changes. But apparently we never make the same suggestions according to Jeebus, that's a false statement, and he's just saying to try and annoy me.. he's trolling me.

And a 2/2 for one is good, and if he had Kird they'd be in his deck, don't you think he'd have noticed them,,, For his card pool, i think he did fine, if he wants to go buy more cards then there are many card he can look into buying more of. I think he should play with his deck first before he buys more.

Quote:

Your entire last post was wrong advice, not the same advice. And your opinion IS wrong, so you shouldn't give it as it won't help him learn anything

You're an arrogant SOB, to think you can't get it wrong... I accept no more critism from you... until you've earned the right to give it to me.

I'll let Jeebus take over for all future posting of your deck Ba'al, unless Ba'al specifically asks me. I'm dissappointed in the spammy stop posts, you guys should not be wasting posts with those spammy things.